Fear Street: Prom Queen (2025) Movie Review – Where to Watch Online
After the wildly successful and genre-blending Fear Street trilogy of 2021, Netflix returns with a new entry in the universe: Fear Street: Prom Queen (2025). Directed by Matt Palmer and based on R.L. Stine’s classic book, this 1980s-inspired slasher aimed to both continue and expand the Fear Street mythology. Unfortunately, the result feels more like a nostalgic cash-in than a true continuation of what made the trilogy resonate so powerfully with fans.
Set in 1988, the movie centers around the prom queen race at Shadyside High. But when the popular girls start vanishing one by one, what should’ve been a glitzy night of teenage dreams turns into a blood-soaked nightmare. Is this just another slasher flick or a worthy entry in the beloved Fear Street saga?
Let’s dive deep.
Plot Summary: A Prom Night to Die For
Lori Granger (India Fowler), the underdog with a dark family past, finds herself unwillingly pulled into the bloodbath of Shadyside High’s prom festivities. While the popular Tiffany Falconer (Fina Strazza) and her clique of queen bee wannabes (nicknamed “The Wolfpack”) dominate the social scene, something sinister stalks the halls.
One by one, the candidates for prom queen start meeting gruesome ends. Cue the masked killer, dressed in a red rain poncho and wielding anything sharp enough to maim. Is the killer an angry outcast? A supernatural entity? Or just another teen fueled by revenge?
What follows is a rollercoaster of 80s throwback set pieces, familiar horror tropes, and an occasionally confusing narrative filled with red herrings and poorly explained motives.
Performance & Characters: Style Over Substance
India Fowler does what she can with the character of Lori, but even the most capable actor struggles when given little to work with. Megan (Suzanna Son) emerges as a bright spot, offering energy and a splash of humor, though her devotion to Lori borders on the obsessive. Sadly, the rest of the cast—including Tiffany, Tyler (David Iacono), and the Wolfpack—fall into one-dimensional stereotypes without meaningful development.
Matt Palmer’s direction lacks the finesse of Leigh Janiak, who helmed the original trilogy. Palmer opts for style over substance, relying heavily on 80s visual cues, synth-pop tracks, and garish prom outfits instead of building tension or emotional stakes.
Visuals & Soundtrack: A Double-Edged Sword
The film leans heavily on its 80s aesthetic. From shoulder pads to big hair and neon lighting, the costume and set designers went all in. Some viewers may enjoy the commitment to retro style, while others might find it overbearing—especially when used to mask an underwhelming script.
Musically, the soundtrack delivers fun needle drops, but they’re often poorly timed or used to inject forced energy into otherwise flat scenes. A bizarre dance-off to Laura Branigan’s “Gloria” feels like parody rather than homage.
Themes & Tonal Issues: Where’s the Fear?
Where the original trilogy managed to layer supernatural lore with commentary on marginalization and trauma, Prom Queen strips away all nuance. Instead of cursed killers possessed by ancient evil, we get… confused motivations and random revenge plots.
There’s a clear shift from supernatural horror to a more grounded slasher vibe, which wouldn’t be a problem if the story held together. Unfortunately, it doesn’t. The killer’s motive, once revealed, feels contrived and disconnected from the broader Fear Street mythology. Fans hoping for callbacks to Sarah Fier or deeper lore connections will be sorely disappointed.
Where to Watch Fear Street: Prom Queen (2025) Online
Streaming Services
-
Netflix – Fear Street: Prom Queen is a Netflix Original and currently available for streaming exclusively on the platform.
👉 Watch on Netflix
Rental & Purchase Options
Since this is a Netflix exclusive, the film is not available on other platforms like Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV+, or Google Play for rent or purchase at this time.
If you’re not a subscriber, consider a one-month trial or basic plan to watch.
Critical & Fan Reception: A Divided Dance Floor
What fans are saying:
-
Many long-time fans of the trilogy called the film “disconnected” and “mediocre at best,” citing poor plot development, lack of continuity with the Sarah Fier saga, and uninspired kills.
-
Some found the aesthetic and gore entertaining enough for a casual watch, dubbing it “fun, campy slasher fluff.”
-
Others were disappointed by the lack of diversity, character depth, or even a connection to the haunting psychological underpinnings that made the original trilogy compelling.
Still, not all is lost. There are hints of a larger story in a post-credits scene—potentially teasing a return to deeper lore in a future installment.
Final Verdict: Missed Crown, Missed Opportunity
Fear Street: Prom Queen tries hard to channel the magic of the 2021 trilogy but ends up feeling like a filler episode rather than a continuation or reinvention. While the 80s flair and gory kills offer fleeting fun, the lack of narrative cohesion, shallow characters, and deviation from established lore make it a disappointing entry for long-time fans.
That said, if you’re looking for a quick horror fix with retro vibes, it’s worth a one-time watch—just don’t expect it to live up to its name or predecessors.
Should You Watch It?
🎬 Stream it on Netflix if you’re a fan of 80s slashers and don’t mind campy, lightweight horror.
🤔 Skip it if you’re invested in the Fear Street universe and expecting rich storytelling or emotional depth.
👉 Watch Fear Street: Prom Queen now on Netflix and judge for yourself.
