I Know Who Killed Me (2007) Movie Review
“I Know Who Killed Me,” directed by Chris Sivertson, is a psychological thriller starring Lindsay Lohan in a dual role. The film attempts to blend elements of mystery, horror, and psychological drama but has been met with largely negative reviews. Despite its shortcomings, it has garnered a cult following for its unusual plot and Lohan’s performance. This review will explore the plot, characters, special effects, and where you can stream it today.
Plot Summary
The film follows Aubrey Fleming (Lindsay Lohan), a talented high school student and aspiring writer, who is abducted by a sadistic serial killer. She is discovered weeks later, barely alive and missing a hand and leg. However, when she regains consciousness, she insists that she is not Aubrey, but Dakota Moss, a street-smart stripper who has no recollection of Aubrey’s life.
The story then unfolds as Dakota, with the help of Aubrey’s parents and her boyfriend Jared (Brian Geraghty), tries to piece together what happened. As Dakota delves deeper into Aubrey’s life, she uncovers disturbing secrets and connections between herself and Aubrey, suggesting a deeper, possibly supernatural link.
Characters and Performances
Lindsay Lohan as Aubrey Fleming/Dakota Moss
Lindsay Lohan delivers a challenging performance, playing two distinct characters. As Aubrey, she portrays a privileged, artistic young woman, while Dakota is rougher and more streetwise. Despite the film’s flaws, Lohan’s commitment to these dual roles is evident, showcasing her range as an actress.
Brian Geraghty as Jared
Brian Geraghty plays Jared, Aubrey’s boyfriend, who is determined to help Dakota uncover the truth. His performance is earnest, adding a layer of sincerity and emotional depth to the film. Jared’s unwavering support for Dakota highlights the character’s loyalty and love.
Julia Ormond as Susan Fleming
Julia Ormond portrays Susan Fleming, Aubrey’s mother, whose grief and confusion are palpable. Ormond’s performance is one of the stronger aspects of the film, as she effectively conveys a mother’s anguish and desperation.
Neal McDonough as Daniel Fleming
Neal McDonough plays Daniel Fleming, Aubrey’s father, who is skeptical of Dakota’s claims but ultimately wants to protect his family. McDonough brings a sense of authority and vulnerability to the role, balancing the character’s conflicting emotions.
Visuals and Special Effects
“I Know Who Killed Me” utilizes a distinct visual style, with a heavy emphasis on blue and red color schemes to differentiate between Aubrey’s and Dakota’s worlds. This stylistic choice, while visually striking, sometimes feels overdone and detracts from the narrative.
The special effects, particularly the depiction of Aubrey’s injuries, are convincing and add a visceral element to the film. The practical effects used for the amputations are particularly noteworthy, contributing to the horror aspect of the film.
Script and Direction
The script, written by Jeff Hammond, is ambitious but ultimately convoluted. The film attempts to weave together elements of a psychological thriller, horror, and supernatural mystery, but the disparate elements do not always cohere. The dialogue is often clunky, with exposition-heavy scenes that feel forced.
Chris Sivertson’s direction shows flashes of creativity, particularly in the film’s visual style and atmosphere. However, the pacing is uneven, with some scenes dragging while others feel rushed. The film’s tone oscillates between serious and unintentionally campy, making it difficult to discern whether the film is meant to be taken seriously or viewed as a genre pastiche.
Nostalgia Factor
“I Know Who Killed Me” has gained a cult following, in part due to Lindsay Lohan’s high-profile career and the film’s bizarre plot. For fans of 2000s thrillers, the film offers a nostalgic look back at a time when Lohan was transitioning from her Disney roots to more mature roles. The film’s campy elements and over-the-top storyline have also made it a favorite among fans of so-bad-it’s-good cinema.
Streaming and Rental Options in America
As of 2024, “I Know Who Killed Me” (2007) is available on several streaming platforms and rental services in the United States:
- Amazon Prime Video: You can rent or purchase the film in HD quality.
- iTunes: Available for rent or purchase.
- Google Play Movies: Offers both rental and purchase options.
- Vudu: Available for rent or purchase.
- YouTube Movies: You can rent or buy the film here as well.
- Tubi: Sometimes available for free with ads.
These options ensure that whether you prefer to own a digital copy or just watch it once, you have plenty of choices.
Conclusion
“I Know Who Killed Me” (2007) is a film that defies easy categorization. While it suffers from a convoluted plot and uneven execution, it offers a unique viewing experience with its bold visual style and Lindsay Lohan’s dual performance. For fans of psychological thrillers and campy horror, the film provides an intriguing, if flawed, exploration of identity and trauma. Stream it on your preferred platform to witness a film that, despite its flaws, remains a curious and memorable entry in the thriller genre.
