Smiley (2012) Movie Review: A Modern Urban Legend Reimagined
“Smiley,” directed by Michael J. Gallagher and released in 2012, is a horror film that taps into the zeitgeist of internet culture and urban legends. With its focus on a sinister figure born from the dark corners of the web, the film attempts to explore the fears and anxieties associated with the digital age. While it offers a fresh premise, “Smiley” struggles with execution, leading to mixed reactions from audiences and critics alike.
Plot Overview
The film follows Ashley (Caitlin Gerard), a college student who moves in with her new roommate, Proxy (Melanie Papalia). Proxy introduces Ashley to an online video chat platform where they encounter an urban legend about a killer named Smiley. According to the legend, if a user types “I did it for the lulz” three times, Smiley (portrayed by Michael Traynor) will appear and murder the person they are chatting with.
Intrigued and skeptical, Ashley and Proxy test the legend, only to witness a horrifying murder on their screen. As Ashley becomes increasingly paranoid, she starts to believe that Smiley is real and is coming after her. The film explores themes of paranoia, the consequences of internet anonymity, and the blurred lines between reality and the digital world.
Character Dynamics and Performances
Caitlin Gerard delivers a compelling performance as Ashley, portraying her descent into paranoia and fear with conviction. Her character’s journey from skepticism to terror is believable and adds depth to the film. Melanie Papalia’s Proxy serves as a contrasting presence, embodying the carefree and reckless attitude often associated with internet culture.
The supporting cast includes notable performances from Shane Dawson as Binder, a conspiracy theorist who provides comic relief, and Roger Bart as Professor Clayton, who offers philosophical insights into the nature of evil and anonymity. Their characters add layers to the narrative, though some of their subplots feel underdeveloped.
Visual Style and Production Design
“Smiley” employs a modern, digital aesthetic that reflects its internet-centric plot. The film makes effective use of online chat interfaces and video feeds, creating a sense of immediacy and immersion. The titular character, Smiley, is visually striking with his grotesque, stitched face resembling a smiley emoticon, which is both creepy and memorable.
The film’s production design is minimalistic, focusing on familiar settings like college campuses and suburban homes, which contrasts effectively with the unsettling nature of the plot. The cinematography captures the claustrophobic feeling of being watched, enhancing the horror elements.
Themes and Social Commentary
“Smiley” delves into themes relevant to the digital age, such as the impact of internet culture on real life, the dangers of anonymity, and the psychological effects of online interactions. The film critiques the desensitization to violence and the voyeuristic tendencies that can arise from prolonged exposure to disturbing content online.
The legend of Smiley serves as a metaphor for the darker aspects of the internet, where anonymity can foster malicious behavior without accountability. The film also explores the idea of collective belief giving rise to real-world consequences, a modern twist on traditional urban legends.
Reception and Legacy
“Smiley” received mixed to negative reviews from critics. While its premise and social commentary were praised, the film’s execution and pacing were often criticized. Some viewers appreciated the film’s attempt to address contemporary issues through horror, while others felt it failed to deliver the scares and coherence expected from the genre.
Despite its mixed reception, “Smiley” has found a place in the horror community, particularly among those interested in internet-based horror stories. It stands as an example of how modern technology and age-old fears can intersect to create new forms of storytelling.
Streaming and Purchase Options in America
For those interested in watching “Smiley,” the film is available on various streaming platforms. As of 2024, you can stream it on Amazon Prime Video and Hulu. It is also available for rental or purchase on platforms like Google Play Movies, YouTube, and iTunes. These options provide flexibility for viewers to choose the most convenient way to watch the film, whether through a subscription service or a one-time rental/purchase.
Conclusion
“Smiley” (2012) is a horror film that taps into the fears and anxieties of the digital age, offering a unique premise centered around an internet urban legend. While it may not fully succeed in delivering a cohesive and terrifying experience, it provides a thought-provoking exploration of the darker side of online culture. With a blend of modern aesthetics and traditional horror elements, “Smiley” is worth a watch for those intrigued by the intersection of technology and terror.
For viewers interested in contemporary horror that reflects current societal issues, “Smiley” offers a distinct and unsettling narrative. Whether you’re a fan of urban legends or exploring the influence of the internet on horror, this film provides a chilling reminder of how easily our online actions can manifest real-world consequences.
