A Mistake (2024) Movie Review: A Tale of Medical Ethics and Professional Unraveling
Director Christine Jeffs makes her much-anticipated return with A Mistake, a thought-provoking drama centered on medical ethics, human error, and the repercussions of a single lapse in judgment. Starring Elizabeth Banks as a gifted surgeon, the film tackles complex themes of accountability and the fragility of professional reputation in a high-stakes medical environment. Jeffs, known for her sensitive and restrained storytelling, last delivered the indie hit Sunshine Cleaning in 2008, and with A Mistake, she revisits the intense character-driven narratives that earned her acclaim with her earlier work Rain (2001).
In this review, we’ll explore the key themes of the movie, provide insights into the performances, and guide you on how to stream A Mistake online in the U.S.
Plot Summary
A Mistake tells the story of Elizabeth Taylor (Elizabeth Banks), a respected surgeon working at a hospital in Auckland, New Zealand. The plot is set in motion when Elizabeth is called to perform what initially seems like a routine operation on a young patient named Lisa (Acacia O’Connor). However, a small error by a trainee during surgery spirals out of control, leading to a catastrophic outcome. As the patient dies from septicemia, Elizabeth finds herself at the center of an investigation, both internally and externally, into the event.
What complicates matters further is the hospital’s new transparency policy, which requires surgeons’ outcomes to be made public. Under pressure from hospital bureaucrat Andrew McGrath (Simon McBurney), Elizabeth must decide whether to protect her reputation by covering up the mistake or face the consequences of disclosing the truth.
The film intricately weaves medical drama with personal turmoil as Elizabeth’s professional relationships, particularly with her colleague and romantic partner Robin (Mickey Sumner), begin to crumble. Her world spirals further out of control as her personal life suffers, including a tragic incident involving a dog she’s temporarily caring for.
Elizabeth Banks’ Standout Performance
Elizabeth Banks, known for her versatility across genres, delivers a powerful, nuanced performance as Dr. Elizabeth Taylor. Banks brings a compelling depth to the character, showcasing the internal struggle of a woman whose confidence and skill are suddenly questioned. Her portrayal is subtle yet deeply resonant, making Taylor both relatable and tragically flawed. Banks’ ability to navigate the emotional intensity of the role without succumbing to melodrama underscores her range as an actor.
Her character’s name, Elizabeth Taylor, may initially distract viewers due to its association with the iconic Hollywood star, but Banks quickly shifts focus away from this coincidence with her riveting portrayal of a surgeon grappling with moral dilemmas and professional collapse.
Christine Jeffs’ Direction: A Thoughtful Examination of Medical Ethics
Director Christine Jeffs’ approach to the material is measured, favoring slow-burning tension over high-stakes drama. The film delves deeply into the complexities of medical ethics, bureaucracy, and the psychological toll that a single mistake can have on even the most capable of professionals. Jeffs’ screenplay, adapted from Carl Shuker’s 2019 novel, raises important questions about accountability in the medical field while also exploring themes of personal integrity.
Jeffs captures the sterility of hospital settings with a cool, understated visual style, reinforcing the isolation felt by Elizabeth as her colleagues and even her lover begin to distance themselves from her. The film’s restrained tone complements its focus on the emotional and moral turmoil of its protagonist, making it a compelling watch for those interested in complex, character-driven narratives.
Where to Watch A Mistake Online in the U.S.
As A Mistake gains traction following its U.S. theatrical release, many viewers are eager to know where they can stream it online. The film, distributed by Quiver Distribution, is available through various streaming platforms, both for rental and purchase. Here are the best options:
Streaming Services
- Amazon Prime Video: Available for rent or purchase. The film can be streamed in HD and 4K, making it a convenient option for viewers who prefer flexibility in their viewing experience.
- Apple TV: Like Amazon, A Mistake is available on Apple TV for rent or purchase. Apple users can enjoy the film on their devices, ensuring seamless integration with other Apple products.
- Google Play Movies & TV: Another excellent platform to stream the film, offering competitive rental and purchase options in high definition.
- Vudu: For those who prefer to use Vudu, the platform offers the movie in both rental and purchase formats. Vudu often provides discounts for first-time users or bundle purchases.
- YouTube Movies: A Mistake can also be streamed through YouTube’s Movies section, allowing viewers to rent or buy the film directly from the site.
Themes and Takeaways
A Mistake does not shy away from the complex realities of medical practice, where a seemingly minor error can have life-altering consequences. It raises essential questions about the role of transparency in healthcare, the pressures faced by medical professionals, and the fine line between personal responsibility and systemic failure.
While the film can feel a bit slow-paced at times, its strength lies in its performances and the moral ambiguity it presents. The character of Elizabeth Taylor is not a clear-cut hero or villain; she is a human being, prone to mistakes and influenced by the high-pressure environment in which she works. This complexity makes A Mistake an absorbing watch, even if the movie lacks the conventional cathartic payoff.
Conclusion
A Mistake is a thought-provoking and well-acted film that takes a deep dive into the moral and ethical dilemmas faced by healthcare professionals. Elizabeth Banks delivers one of her best performances, and Christine Jeffs proves that she remains a master of intelligent, character-driven storytelling. While not a fast-paced medical thriller, A Mistake offers a nuanced, contemplative look at the human side of medicine.
